Middle management is at a crossroads

Step into any office today, and there's a quiet revolution you might not see at first. It's happening every day - in the way teams interact, in the decisions that unfold in meeting rooms and on calls. Forget the grand narratives about AI taking over; this is about how it's changing the role of those at the heart of our teams – the middle managers.

Subtle for now, yet it's reshaping how we lead and how we work together. This change isn’t about machines; it's about people and the new dynamics emerging in the places we work every day.

The two faces of AI: A realist’s viewpoint 

When contemplating the intersection of AI and middle management, it's essential to wear two hats – that of a realist and an optimist. The realist in me sees AI as a double-edged sword. There's undeniable efficiency and precision in AI's approach to tasks that once consumed a manager's day.

But there's a flip side – the risk of dehumanising the workplace and turning managerial roles into overseers of algorithms rather than leaders of people.

• The optimist's perspective: The optimist in me envisions a scenario where AI becomes the ultimate assistant – a tool that elevates the role of middle managers from taskmasters to strategic thinkers. In this future, AI handles the mundane, while managers focus on the creative, the human, the visionary.

• The realist's acknowledgement: However, the realist recognises that some, or all, traditional aspects of middle management will become obsolete. There's no shying away from this. In sectors where efficiency is paramount, AI will very likely streamline entire layers of management. This isn't necessarily catastrophic, but it's a significant shift, requiring a redefinition of career paths and skill sets.

The financial sector provides a compelling case study. Here, AI has automated certain tasks, but it hasn't replaced the human element in decision-making. Managers have adapted, becoming interpreters of AI-generated data, guiding strategy with a blend of machine efficiency and human insight.

While specific percentages vary, recent research, including insights from McKinsey and Deloitte, indicates a significant trend towards using AI to enhance employee performance, rather than replacing it.

This trend is seen across various industries, with AI being used to improve operations, support better decision-making, and free workers from repetitive tasks, thus enhancing their roles. While this shift is promising, it also introduces new challenges. Enhancing performance through AI means embracing change, and adapting to these changes can be a complex process.

However, it's crucial to remember: the core aim of businesses – prioritising shareholders and profits – hasn't changed. This fact is as true today as it has ever been. It's an important consideration for anyone in middle management or moving into these roles - plan and adapt with this most important truth in mind.

The future manager's profile

The successful future manager will likely be someone who can dance with AI, not fight it. They'll need to be agile, adaptable, and continually learning. They'll need to understand AI's capabilities, but more importantly, they'll need to master the art of blending these capabilities with the uniquely human skills of empathy, creativity, and ethical leadership.

Alongside the practical aspects of AI integration, there's an often-overlooked dimension that future-forward managers must grapple with: ethics. The optimist in me sees this as a golden opportunity for middle managers to become standard-bearers of ethical AI use.

The realist, however, acknowledges the complexity of this terrain. AI, in its current form, is a mirror of our society – it can perpetuate biases and inequalities if not governed thoughtfully. The responsibility falls on the shoulders of middle managers to not only understand the workings of AI but to ensure its application upholds the highest ethical standards.

This involves continuous learning about AI ethics, actively participating in shaping organizational policies around AI, and being vigilant about its impact on team dynamics and decision-making processes. It's about being the moral compass in a landscape where technology's capabilities often outpace our ability to fully comprehend their long-term implications.

The collapsed talent stack scenario

Now imagine a future where middle management as we know it is reimagined, or even phased out, influenced by concepts like Scott Belsky's 'collapsing the talent stack'.

In such a world, AI doesn't just automate tasks but also blends roles, making each team member's contributions more interdisciplinary. This concept, seen in startups and increasingly in larger companies, suggests a shift where middle managers might need to evolve into roles that amalgamate leadership, product development, and direct customer engagement.

This change, driven by the need for agility and faster decision-making, could see middle managers becoming more like versatile leaders, adept in various aspects of business from technology to design thinking.

For those in middle management or aspiring to such roles, the next 3-5 years could be pivotal in acquiring diverse skills and embracing AI as a key element of strategic operations. It's a future where the ability to adapt, learn continuously, and maintain a strong narrative and empathetic connection could be essential to get ahead.

Looking ahead

Let's ground our perspective in practicality. The coming years are not just about theoretical changes; we’re dealing with real-world actions and decisions that middle managers will face.

It's clear that AI is reshaping the landscape, but it's not an all-consuming wave that wipes the slate clean. Instead, it's a tool that redefines roles and opens up new possibilities.

The savvy middle manager of the future will look at AI as an opportunity to enhance their role, not as a threat. They will be the ones finding creative and new ways to integrate AI into their teams, ensuring it complements human skills rather than replaces them.

However, amidst all this technological evolution, the core of management remains the same - people. It's about understanding your team, motivating them, and steering them towards common goals. Technology is just a part of the toolkit. The real essence of management – guiding, inspiring, and leading – remains as vital as ever.

So, for those in middle management today or aspiring to be there tomorrow, the message is to embrace the change. Learn about AI, sure, but also keep honing those timeless skills of leadership, empathy, and strategic thinking.

The future belongs to those who can blend the best of both worlds – the efficiency and insights of AI with the irreplaceable human touch of leadership.

What else is top of mind for you right now? Let me know by voting or hit reply, I read every single response.

Mindaugas

P.S. Our quarterly curated peer groups will give you your private board of directors, guaranteed to boost your career and life - 1800 of your peers from Netflix, Airbnb, and Shopify have already joined them. If you’re interested, sign up here.

P.P.S. You might’ve noticed more regular activity from us here - we have a lot to say and talk about how careers are evolving. Expect a weekly article on the future of careers and a once-a-month round-up of things you should know about.